Macarons are wonderful, beautiful little things that are sweet and scrumptious. Very difficult to make, but wonderful to eat and everyone has their own opinion on what makes a macaron great.
I can’t say I’m a macaron connoisseur, but while I love making macarons (any not always successful), I had the pleasure of sampling a bunch of different macarons while in Paris. It seems like every patisserie in Paris carries them and I just couldn’t help it, I’ve tried pretty much every one I came across…(I know what you are thinking: chubby). Yes, I admit, I’m getting chubby, but enjoying every delicious bite of it!
For me, while romping through the streets of Paris, basically 5 things struck me as elements to a macaron (you’ll probably have your own 5, please let me know if you do).
Colour – Macarons are bright and colorful. But sometimes that’s easier said then done. Too dark of a colour and it looks like are pumping it full of colouring. Too bright and it looks like it is radioactive. Not enough colour and well it just ain’t attractive.
Crispiness – When eating a macaron, the all important part is the shell. It should be delicate but firm and collapse at the slightest pressure. This is also telling of whether the macaron is freshly made or has been sitting for a couple days. The best macarons should fall apart as if it was cotton candy melting as soon as it touches your lips.
Chewiness – After the shell collapses, the second layer of the macaron should be nice and chewy almost like a jelly bean or sugus candy (but not as hard).
Filling – While there are different jams and fillers, this is where the great macarons are differentiated from the good macarons. Chefs can work wonders with this thin layer of yummy jelly.
Value – Yes, since I’m actually paying for them now, value is very important. Many places are in the neighborhood of €0.7-2. In Hong Kong these same macarons will sell for HK$30-HK$50… so yah, they are much more value for money there.